RUSHIL DECOR

HPL against daily wear: what abrasion and scratch studies measured

Desks, counters and cabinet fronts are judged by how they look after years of use. Laboratory studies from Türkiye and Norway have measured how HPL resists abrasion and scratching, and what makes one surface tougher than another.

6 min readUpdated Oct 22, 2026

In short

  • In a comparison of four finishes on particleboard, HPL recorded the highest scratch and abrasion resistance and wood veneer the lowest.
  • The wear layer makes the difference: a laminate with a barrier and an aluminium oxide overlay lasted 12 433 cycles against 359 for a standard one — about 35 times as many.
  • Rushil's data sheets report more than 400 wear revolutions for Decorative HPL and 450 for TOPAZ, against the required 150, and scratch grade 5 for TOPAZ.
Kitchen island with a black marble-effect compact worktop and waterfall end, bar stools and dark cabinetry
A compact kitchen island in a marble-effect décor. Worktops like this meet abrasion and scratching every day; the wear layer decides how they age.Image: Rushil Decor, Compact Verse catalogue

How this review was put together

This article summarises four peer-reviewed laboratory studies: a comparison of decorative finishes from Karadeniz Technical University in Türkiye (Nemli, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 2008); a study of HPL layer structures from Gazi University and Karadeniz Technical University, tested in the laboratories of the Turkish Standards Institution (Burdurlu and Özgenç, Forest Products Journal, 2009); work on scratch-resistant overlays by researchers at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology and the RISE PFI institute in Trondheim (Rusu et al., Coatings, 2018); and a study of press settings for melamine-faced particleboard from Karadeniz Technical University and Oklahoma State University (Nemli and Hiziroglu, Journal of Composite Materials, 2009). All four tested laboratory samples. The papers are listed at the end.

Four finishes, and HPL came first

Gökay Nemli faced particleboard with four common decorative finishes, wood veneer, continuous pressed laminate (CPL), high-pressure laminate and finish foil, and tested how well each resisted scratching and abrasion. HPL recorded the highest scratch and abrasion resistance of the four; the veneered boards recorded the lowest. On the veneers, a polyurethane varnish outperformed a cellulosic one, and the structure of the CPL made no measurable difference.

For a furniture maker or shopfitter this is the case for HPL in a single comparison: on the same board, the high-pressure laminate face stood up best to the two kinds of damage a desk, counter or cabinet front meets every day. The study ranks the samples it tested rather than every product on the market.

One extra layer, 35 times the wear

How much an HPL resists wear depends on what sits on top of the décor paper. Burdurlu and Özgenç pressed five laminate constructions and tested them to EN 438. The standard laminate lasted 359 cycles in the surface-wear test. Adding a barrier layer, an overlay or both raised that to between 488 and 659 cycles. A barrier with an aluminium oxide overlay reached 12,433 cycles, about 35 times the standard construction and the only one rated at the higher wear level.

The aluminium oxide overlay improved more than wear. That construction scored the top grade for ink staining and cigarette burns, where the standard laminate scored 2, and it swelled least in boiling water: 15.5 % in thickness against 20.5 %. The authors conclude that the aluminium oxide overlay contributed positively to every resistance property tested. Scratch resistance stayed at 5 N, which is why EN 438 grades wear and scratching as separate properties.

1st of 4
HPL's rank for scratch and abrasion resistance against veneer, CPL and finish foil
Nemli 2008
35×
wear cycles with a barrier and aluminium oxide overlay: 12,433 against 359
Burdurlu 2009
6 N
scratch resistance with 10 % treated alumina particles; 4 N without
Rusu 2018
108 µm
width of the remaining scratch, against 131 µm without particles
Rusu 2018
> 400
revolutions to the initial wear point, Rushil Decorative HPL; 150 required
Rushil TDS
450
revolutions for the TOPAZ compact worktop, with scratch resistance at grade 5
Rushil TDS
HPL against daily wear in six numbers.Diagram drawn for this site from the figures in the article

Treated particles, narrower scratches

The aluminium oxide in an overlay is also where scratch resistance is made. The Trondheim team prepared overlays for high-pressure floor laminate with alumina particles, and treated some of the particles with a silane coupling agent so that they bonded better to the melamine resin. In the Taber scratch test to EN 438-2, the overlay with 10 % treated particles resisted 6 N, against 4 N for the overlay without particles, and the scratch it left was narrower: 108 ± 7 µm against 131 ± 5 µm. A narrower scratch is a less visible one.

The treatment made the difference. With untreated particles, raising the content from 5 % to 10 % lowered the result from 5 N to 4 N, which the authors suggest may come from particles clumping together. These were experimental overlays, but they show why the make-up of a wear layer, not only its presence, decides how well a surface hides daily scratches.

The press cycle makes the surface

Nemli and Hiziroglu pressed particleboard overlaid with melamine-impregnated paper at 170, 185 and 205 °C for 18 to 46 seconds. Scratch and abrasion resistance rose with pressing time at every temperature; going from 185 to 205 °C made no significant difference, and 170 °C for 46 seconds gave the best surfaces. The share of resin taken up by the paper, between 30 and 60 %, also mattered. The study concerns melamine-faced board rather than HPL, but the lesson carries over: a durable surface is the product of a controlled press cycle and the right resin content, which is why laminates are tested and classified to EN 438 rather than judged by eye.

Reading wear and scratch on a data sheet

A laminate data sheet gives wear and scratching on two separate lines. The EN 438-2 wear test counts the revolutions of an abrasive wheel until the décor first wears through, the initial point; the grades in Rushil's data sheets require at least 150. Scratch resistance is graded by the force at which a scratch becomes visible. The Turkish study used an older calculation that averages the initial and final wear points, so its cycle counts are not directly comparable with initial-point figures.

Rushil's data sheets report, to the initial point, more than 400 revolutions for Decorative HPL and 450 for the TOPAZ compact worktop, against the required 150, and scratch resistance at grade 5 for TOPAZ, against the stated requirement of grade 2 for smooth and grade 3 for textured finishes. These are test results, not a declaration of conformity.

What this means for furniture, counters and shopfitting

Taken together, the studies make a clear case. In a direct comparison of four common finishes, HPL resisted scratching and abrasion best. The wear layer is where performance is built: an aluminium oxide overlay multiplied wear resistance about 35 times and improved resistance to stains, burns and boiling water as well, while treated particles raise scratch resistance and make scratches less visible. And because wear and scratching are separate properties, a good specification names both, as an EN 438 data sheet does.

For desks, reception counters, cabinet fronts and shop fittings, Rushil's Decorative HPL brings an EN 438-tested surface to the substrate of your choice. For worktops and counters in daily kitchen and hospitality use, the TOPAZ compact laminate adds a solid, self-supporting panel with the wear and scratch results above. Samples and data sheets for both are available on request.

Common questions

Is HPL more scratch-resistant than veneer or foil?

In the Karadeniz Technical University comparison of four finishes on particleboard, HPL recorded the highest scratch and abrasion resistance and wood veneer the lowest, with continuous pressed laminate and finish foil in between. The ranking applies to the samples tested.

What makes one HPL more wear-resistant than another?

Mainly the layer on top of the décor. In tests at the Turkish Standards Institution, a standard laminate lasted 359 cycles and a laminate with a barrier and an aluminium oxide overlay 12,433, about 35 times as many. Ask for the wear result of the exact grade you specify.

What wear and scratch results do Rushil's data sheets report?

To EN 438-2, Rushil reports more than 400 revolutions to the initial wear point for Decorative HPL and 450 for TOPAZ, against a requirement of 150, and scratch resistance at grade 5 for TOPAZ. These are test results, not a declaration of conformity; the data sheets are on the downloads page.

Sources

  1. Journal of Materials Processing Technology 195(1–3), Nemli G. — Factors affecting some quality properties of the decorative surface overlaysJan 1, 2008 · en
  2. Forest Products Journal 59(4), Burdurlu E., Özgenç Ö. — Effect of different layer structures on some resistance characteristics of high-pressure laminatesApr 1, 2009 · en
  3. Coatings 8(6), Rusu C. L., Brodin M., Hausvik T. I., Hindersland L. K. et al. — The Potential of Functionalized Ceramic Particles in Coatings for Improved Scratch ResistanceJun 19, 2018 · en
  4. Journal of Composite Materials 43(13), Nemli G., Hiziroglu S. — Effect of Press Parameters on Scratch and Abrasion Resistance of Overlaid Particleboard PanelsJun 8, 2009 · en
  5. Rushil Decor — Decorative HPL (HGS/VGS) — Product Data Sheeten
  6. Rushil Decor — VIR TOPAZ (CGS / CGF) — Product Data Sheeten

Compiled for this site from the publications listed above. Summaries are in our own words, not quotations — read the originals for the full argument.

Technical data is based on manufacturer documentation and applicable test reports. Product specifications may vary by grade, thickness, décor, manufacturing batch or application. Please request the latest technical documentation before final specification or installation.